Why money matters

I think this is an absolutely fantastic, clear and concise explanation for why money matters in macroeconomics:

In normal times, people receive apples and money from the sky in the form of endowments (i.e. their wealth), and they make decisions about how to balance their cash and apple balances. Apples are transacted, bellies are filled, and life is good.
But suddenly, a recession hits. What does this look like? By definition, a recession is when there is a general glut of goods that aren’t consumed. In this toy economy, this corresponds to a situation in which some people have apples but choose not to eat them! This may seem peculiar, but remember that the market for apples in this model represents a composite of all goods markets. So it could be the case that while everybody has apples, some want Red Delicious while others are looking for the tartness of Granny Smith. In more formal economic models, this is glibly incorporated by requiring that people do not consume their own endowment and instead trade for consumption. In any case, apples aren’t eaten and we have a rotten general glut.

But this seems peculiar — aren’t markets supposed to clear? Not necessarily. Prices don’t always adjust instantly, so we can have excess supplies and excess demands. However, economists do have a way to constrain what this non-clearing state looks like. In particular, according to Walras’ law, assuming everybody spends all of their wealth, if there are excess supplies (i.e. too much produced) in some markets, then they must add up to excess demands (i.e. too little produced) in other markets. In other words, even if supply does not equal demand in each market, supplies must add up to demands across markets.

The requirement that everybody spends their endowment is crucial. It means that Walras’ law doesn’t apply just to the market for apples because not everybody spends all their wealth on apples. Instead, some people may put their wealth in money. But once we include the money market, we do have the condition that everybody spends their endowment, and therefore Walras’ law does apply to the entire macroeconomy of apples and money.

This leads to the most important conclusion from general equilibrium theory as related to monetary economics:

If there is an excess supply of goods, it must be the result of excess demand for money.

Go read the whole thing and follow Yichuan Wang’s blog. He’s one of the best communicators in economics right now.

3 thoughts on “Why money matters

  1. I always find such discussions of money as a little disconcerting, in particular because they tend to suggest that money have some intrinsic value, or is based on barter. I find Tim Johnson’s basis of money on credit and reciprocity to be much more compelling.

    Of course, it would be completely atypical of me to not include a complexity theoretic result in my comment. It isn’t that prices don’t adjust instantly, in an Arrow-Debreu market, they could easily take exponentially long to adjust because solving the Arrow-Debreu model is PPAD-hard. A more friendly treatment (that I think you might enjoy) is available in, I highly recommend it:

    Roughgarden, T. (2010). Computing equilibria: A computational complexity perspective. Economic Theory, 42:193-236.

    • fyi, I feel bad about not responding to a lot of these comments but I find I’ve been too busy to read the rather…dense…papers that you link to, so they’re all in a folder for me to go through after I submit these two manuscripts I’ve been working on. Then I think I’m going to have a complexity party week

      • No rush! If you start reading something super exciting then send me an email or catch me on G+/blogs. If you find some of the stuff to your interest then I would be excited to do some back-and-forth posts, or you are welcome to write a guest post for TheEGG blog demolishing computational complexity approaches. It would bring some balance to my evangelization of cstheory!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s