Milk: Mini-review

One thing that I have a problem with is remembering why I do or do not like particular things. When I am reading anything by Ian McEwan for instance, I could list fifty or sixty reasons why the book is terrible. A month later? I just remember that I don’t like it. Therefore, there will be mini-reviews of everything I see/hear/read/consume for my future reference.

milk2The first is of Milk. I watched it in Hillcrest last night, followed by a delicious dinner at Kitima Thai (one of my favorite restaurants in San Diego, along with Yakitori Yakyudori and The Linkery). The movie was very good.  I have seen a lot of good acting performances this year, and Sean Penn’s is definitely up there. The story is engrossing, and it got me angry all over again about the intolerance and bigotry behind Prop 8. It really is a shame that this movie did not come out earlier.

What didn’t I like? There were a few too many times when it was clear that this was a movie adaptation of someone’s life. It was pretty obvious when things that were days or months apart happened one after the other. That’s fine for a movie to do, but it shouldn’t be so obviously set up. My bigger complaint – and this is probably a personal preference rather than a valid aesthetic criticism – is that we didn’t see enough development of the characters in the movie. This is not really a movie about Harvey Milk & co., it is a movie about the gay rights campaign and movement in the 70’s. That’s fine, but it would have been nice to learn more about our characters. As it is, most characters are introduced with a short voiceover by Sean Penn and aren’t developed further. Even Milk is a little mysterious: his love affair in the second half of the movie is clearly destructive and unhappy, but we never see why they stay together. What we see is Milk as a political force first, as a person second.

But overall, I thought it was very good. Also, before the movie in the preview for Che , the ending quote is absolutely ridiculous:

Interviewer: How does it feel to be a symbol?

Che: A symbol of what?

Uh, good point. Very dramatic, Steven Soderbergh, very dramatic.

3 thoughts on “Milk: Mini-review

  1. We are going to the movies tonight and are trying to choose between Milk and Frost/Nixon. Everyone I know has liked both of them. But it may be hard to beat Slumdog Millionaire.

  2. I haven’t seen Frost/Nixon yet. I still need to see that, Revolutionary Road, Gran Torino, and The Wrestler to round out the 2008 “Oscar season”. So many!

  3. Having lived in the San Francisco suburbs during the time of the movie I realized how disconnected I was about the events at the time. I read about them in the paper. I was shocked when the murders took place. I was entertained by the idiocy of Anita Bryant. But I was not involved in any way. Now that I am involved in politics I wonder why I was so disengaged before.

    To a certain extent I lived the life of Forest Gump. I was around during the anti-war demonstrations, walked through the Haight Ashbury during the summer of love (1967), fought in the war, had a friend die of AIDs when most people did not know the disease existed, etc., but until 2004 I was not really involved with movements. I look back now and wish I did more. My life would have been richer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s